Best Cookies For Coffee: Easy Pairings Plus Recipe

Cookies and coffee go hand in hand. From deep rich espressos to smooth and creamy lattes, the perfect cookie is out there to elevate your coffee experience. Let’s look at the best cookies for coffee and some delicious cookie-coffee combinations.

Coffee and cookies go together like cake and ice cream or chips and dip. So for coffee lovers, choosing the best cookies for coffee is a great way to enhance the overall experience.

Carefully deciding on the perfect flavor and texture of a cookie to complement coffee is important, and it takes a bit of forethought before choosing.

This article will show you how to best pair your cookies and coffee, and it will provide you with many examples of coffee-cookie combos.

I will also give you a recipe for one of the best cookies ever to pair with coffee. The Italian Biscotti, only vegan style!

This article may contain affiliate links for your convenience. You can read the full disclosure policy.

Cookie Flavor To Complement Your Coffee

When it comes to finding the best cookies for coffee, cookie flavor is important.

The flavor of the cookie can either enhance or compete with the flavor of the coffee, so it is important to be mindful when choosing what flavor of cookie is best.

As an example, a deep, rich chocolate chip cookie is bold and sweet, and it can complement a rich cup of dark roast coffee.

Whereas a citrus-type cookie, like a lemon cookie, is light and refreshing and the perfect cookie to complement a bright acidic coffee. This creates a nice balance of flavors.

So the next time you order a cookie with your cup of coffee, decide if you want to complement or contrast with the flavor of your coffee. This helps to make a great pairing.

Cookie Texture To Enhance Your Cup Of Coffee

Playing around with cookie textures in combination with your cup of joe also enhances the overall experience and enjoyment of the cookie-coffee combo.

A soft and chewy cookie is quite the contrast in texture to a steaming cup of hot coffee. Combining these different textures together creates a nice balance your taste buds will enjoy.

Choosing a hard crunchy delicious cookie in contrast to a smooth bold cup of coffee is also delightful. Sharpening your senses, keeping them alert and satisfied.

Cookie Profiles To Pair With Coffee

Here are some different types of cookies, categorized according to flavor and texture, for when you are trying to decide what kind of cookie to pair with your coffee.

Guidelines For Pairing The Best Cookies With Coffee

When you are trying to decide what kind of cookies to pair with coffee, think about the intensity of your coffee.

To gain the best overall experience and enhance your tastebuds, aim to either match or contrast the intensity of the coffee with the cookies you are choosing.

Here are some general guidelines for pairing light, medium, and dark roast coffee with your favorite cookies.

Light roast coffee pairings

Light roast coffee has a bright and delicate flavor profile. Look for cookies that won’t overpower these subtle notes.

Perfect cookies to pair with light roast coffee: Vanilla cookies, sugar cookies, or citrus zest cookies.

Medium roast coffee pairings

Medium roast coffee strikes the perfect balance between flavor complexity and smoothness. Cookies with a slightly bolder flavor will be perfect with this cup of brew.

Perfect cookies to pair with medium-roast coffee: Chocolate chip cookies, oatmeal raisin cookies. peanut butter cookies, spiced cookies, macaron cookies.

Dark roast coffee pairings

Dark roast coffee has a full-bodied profile with robust flavors and hints of bitterness. To match the intensity of this rich bold flavor, look for cookies that are equally as bold in flavor.

Perfect cookies to pair with dark roast coffee: dark chocolate chunks cookies, espresso cookies, chewy coffee cookies, Italian biscotti cookies, and Snickerdoodle cookies.

The choices are endless when it comes to choosing the best coffee cookie. Consider the intensity of the coffee and match it with the flavor of the cookie.

By exploring complementary and contrasting flavors, you will be creating a beautiful and joyous experience for not just your taste buds but your whole being as well!

Elevate Your Coffee Experience

Finding the best cookies for coffee will truly elevate your coffee experience, and add an extra little lift to your daily coffee routine.

It is important to be mindful of the intensity of the coffee you are drinking but it is also important to consider the texture of the cookies as well.

Whether you are choosing a soft and chewy cookie, or a crispy crunchy cookie, matching the texture of the cookie with the mouthfeel of your coffee will only add to the ultimate coffee experience.

There are many types of cookies to choose from when you are trying to decide the best cookies for your coffee. It is really your personal preference.

The best part is you get to choose! Find the perfect cookie that brings you joy and complements your favorite coffee.

Experiment with different combinations and enjoy the process. Allow yourself to indulge in the perfect harmony of flavors and textures that come with a well-paired cookie and coffee duo.

Treat yourself to the pleasurable art of cookie and coffee pairing, and turn your coffee break into a truly exceptional experience.

Vegan Italian Biscotti Cookies

Biscotti is one of the best cookies for coffee, with its hard crunchy texture they are perfect for dipping gently into your just brewed cup of black coffee – or any style of coffee that you prefer.

Making Italian biscotti as a vegan cookie is not easy because they normally contain eggs but after some trial and error, I have created a delicious vegan Italian biscotti cookie!

Vegan Biscotti Cookies Recipe Notes

Toasting the cookies is important. This step helps to keep the biscotti cookies crunchy but with a nice dense texture on the inside. So don’t skip this step.

Be very careful and take your time when you are cutting the loaf into cookies. It will tend to crumble a bit on the edges if you move too fast.

This cookie dough has zero eggs in it so there is no real tough binder, therefore you must cut the loaf slowly.

You will see that the cookies may not be 100% done on the inside when you cut the loaf. This is perfectly okay, as you will proceed to the second step of toasting them on each side in the oven. This will finish up the cooking process.

These cookies are easy to double or triple, so if you want to make a larger batch, feel free to do so!

Handy Kitchen Tools To Consider

electric hand mixer – I like to use a hand mixer for the majority of my baking, as it allows me to really feel the texture and consistency of the dough and batter.

Although I still really love to use my mom’s old hand-held mixer, I also own this one just in case my mom’s blender suddenly stops working…yikes…I will be so sad!

Baking Sheet – this one is really nice and it comes as a set with different sizes AND includes the silicone baking sheets. I think it’s a really good price and I use all of the sizes absolutely.

silicone baking sheet – again, part of the baking sheet set but they are also sold separately if you already have baking pans and sheets.

Cooling rack – a must for baking. Also included in the baking sheet, and silicone baking sheets set.

glass mixing bowls – this set is perfect, and includes three different sizes. I use them for everything.

silicone spatula – I used to always use wood spoons but I really like these silicone spatulas, especially for batters and dough.

Whisk – needed to combine oil with pretty much any ingredient.

measuring cups – I’ve been using this set for years.

measuring spoons – same with this set. I do have a couple sets of measuring cups and spoons but I do like these because they are wood. Sometimes ingredients can react with metal which is why I often use wood utensils etc.

glass storage container – such a good investment. I rarely use plastic and instead have invested in some good quality glass storage containers that will last a long long time.

Vegan Biscotti Cookies Ingredients

• 3 tbsp ground flax seed
• 1/2 cup olive oil (highly recommend organic, extra virgin)
• 1 cup white sugar (preferably organic)
• 2 tbsp pure anise extract
• 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour (preferably organic)
• 2 tsp baking powder (preferably aluminum-free)
• 1/4 tsp sea salt

Vegan Biscotti Cookies Instructions

Preparation:

In a small bowl, measure out the ground flax and add 1/2 cup of filtered water. Stir until combined. Set aside to thicken.

Measure out the flour and then sift it together with the baking powder and sea salt, into a medium bowl.

Instructions:

In a large bowl add the olive oil and sugar. Combine well, using the electric mixer, until smooth. Scrape down the sides of the bowl occasionally to blend completely.

Add the flax mixture and anise extract and blend well.

Add the sifted flour mixture gradually, blending each time until just combined.

NOTE: Toward the end, you will need to hand blend the remaining flour using your spatula, as the dough will be too heavy and thick for the electric mixer.

NOTE: Do not blend for a long period of time, as this will make the cookies tough. Just enough to get all of the ingredients combined smoothly.

Cover and place the dough in the fridge for 1 hour.

Preheat the oven to 350°F, and place the oven rack on the 1st or 2nd lower shelf.

Once chilled, take the dough out of the fridge and shape it into a medium size loaf approximately 8-10 inches long.

Put the loaf onto the baking sheet/pan and place it in the oven.

Bake for approximately 40-45 minutes, or until the loaf has turned a nice golden color.

Once the loaf has cooked, take it out of the oven and let it cool to the touch.

Once the loaf is cool enough to handle, place it on a cutting board and slice the loaf into approximately 1/2″ pieces (cookies).

Place the cookies back onto the baking sheet/pan, set the rack in your oven on the middle shelf, and let the cookies toast for 6-8 minutes on each side, until they are golden brown and cooked through completely.

NOTE: This is an important step, and assures that the biscotti stays crunchy but dense on the inside.

Once toasted, take the cookies out of the oven and place them on a cooling rack to cool completely.

ENJOY!

How To Store

These cookies will stay fresh for about one week if they are stored in an airtight glass storage container.

You can store them on your kitchen counter or in the fridge if you prefer.

You can also store these cookies in the freezer to eat at a later date, as long as they are stored in a freezer-safe container. These cookies will last in the freezer for up to 6 months.

When you do take them out of the freezer to enjoy, just place them on a rack to defrost first for an hour or so before eating.

Check out these other nourishing recipes and joyful living tips for busy caregivers

Let’s be social

If you make and enjoy this delicious vegan Italian biscotti cookie recipe, I would love it if you give it 5 stars and comment below.

You can also follow me, and my life on Cape Cod, on my Instagram page @parkinsons_and_us.

VIDEO: Choosing the best cookies for coffee and vegan biscotti cookies

Printable recipe for you to enjoy